"The personal attack launched by High Court Judge G.R. Swaminathan is contrary to judicial ethics. The Marxist Communist Party requests the Chief Justice to take appropriate action against him," said the state secretary of the Marxist Communist Party, P. Shanmugam, in a statement.
In it, "High Court Judge G.R. Swaminathan has launched a personal attack against Marxist Communist Party Member of Parliament Comrade Su. Venkatesan, in a manner contrary to judicial ethics and dignity. This is not the first time Judge G.R. Swaminathan has made such remarks. His comments have been increasingly unbecoming, using the prestige of the office he holds in public to undermine it. Several of his speeches, in which casteist thinking appears to dominate, have already sparked controversy.

While commenting on the fake books found in the Coimbatore library, he had said that all the shelves of those libraries called the "Periyar intellectual world" are filled with fake books from publishers like "Agalvilakku." If all the sins caused by those mistakes are to be washed away, then all the volumes of this Mahaperiyava book must be placed on the shelves of all Periyar intellectual world libraries. Only then, I sincerely believe, will all these sins be removed," he had noted. The support for varnashrama and the malice hidden within this view are obvious.
Responding to this, MP Su. Venkatesan said, "What has happened in the library procurement is corruption, and it must be punished according to law. That is the job of judges. To say that what happened is a sin and that it should be atoned for is the job of astrologers. For the wisdom of law, Ambedkar, and for the wisdom of rationalism, Periyar are remembered every day as 'great men,'" he said. Since the remark he made was absurd, the judge has tried to defend himself by saying that he made it only as a joke at the book launch event. In addition, during the hearing, he unnecessarily criticized a Member of Parliament personally and even belittled the travel concession provided by the government.
It is in no way acceptable for a judge to sit in the chair and speak in this manner. He has already, on several occasions, been speaking in a biased manner based on his own ideological stance. It is noteworthy that Members of Parliament have already signed and submitted a notice for a disqualification motion, stating that he is unfit to continue in this position. A judge criticizing the travel he undertakes within the facilities provided by the government to Members of Parliament reveals his ulterior motives and conduct that is inappropriate for the constitutional responsibility he holds.

This is against the dignity of the judiciary. Since what he said in the court has also been reported in the media, the state executive committee of the Marxist Communist Party has stated that the Chief Justice of the High Court should take appropriate action against him and protect the public’s trust in the judiciary as well as its dignity."
It is noteworthy that Judge G.R. Swaminathan had criticized Su. Venkatesan, saying, "For something I said jokingly, he has instructed me on how I should do my work. When I was going to the railway station, a person in luxurious attire got down from a high-end car. Thinking it was someone else, Su. Venkatesan got down from a high-end car in luxurious attire. On the train, Su. Venkatesan went to first class, while I traveled in the ordinary class. I thought to myself that a Communist Party leader was being so luxurious."
