Ramasubbu, a resident of Nellai, had filed a petition in the Madurai Bench of the High Court. In it, he stated, "The court orders issued regarding the purchase of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu in 2024 have not been properly implemented. Books have been purchased for regional libraries in Coimbatore, Tiruchi, Salem, Cuddalore, and Nellai, including the Periyar Arivulaga Library in Coimbatore.
This book procurement was carried out without properly following any of the court’s orders. Therefore, an order should be issued to initiate contempt of court proceedings against the Secretary of the School Education Department, who is responsible for this," he said.
This case came up for hearing yesterday before Judges G.R. Swaminathan and Sumathi. The details of the case filed in the Madras High Court were brought to the judge’s attention.
Following that, the judges asked, "This case can be heard under the supervision of Judge Lakshmi Narayanan. Who is the main reason this mistake happened? There must be someone responsible, right?"

On the government side, it was stated that "Public Libraries Department Director Jayanthi has also served as the secretary of the high-level committee."
The judges instructed that no lawyers need appear on behalf of Jayanthi from the government side.
On librarian Kamatchi’s side, it was stated, "Perumal Murugan has also recommended some books from Agalvilakku Publications. My job is to coordinate the selection committee."
To that, the judge asked, How many years have you been working in the library?
On Kamatchi’s side, it was replied, "19 years."
The judge then asked, "If Perumal Murugan can identify fake books, why can’t you? Everyone agrees that a mistake has occurred. Who is responsible for it?"
On Kamatchi’s side, it was stated, "The books from Agal Vilakku Publications were recommended by the recommendation committee. I only forwarded them to the higher-level committee. I have not made any mistake.
If the details of the recommended emails are submitted, the culprit can be identified," it was said.

On the government side, "26,000 books have been recommended by the recommendation committee. However, many books that were not recommended have been compiled by the coordination committee and sent to the high-level committee.
At present, the inquiry is being conducted only in connection with the Periyar Arivulaga Library. Details have been sought from other libraries. Action has also been taken to freeze another bank account belonging to Mohan of Agal Vilakku Publications. It was stated that Kamatchi had been the head of the coordination committee."
In response, the judge said humorously, "Kamatchi is my wife's name. What I am afraid of now is whether Su. Venkatesan will speak about this too?" and laughed.
On the government side, it was stated that "the tender issued in connection with book procurement has been canceled."
On the petitioner’s side, it was stated, "The high-level committee has not yet been brought to light."
After recording the arguments from all sides, the judges said, "On the government side, details were provided regarding another case filed in the Madras High Court seeking an inquiry into the book procurement irregularities. We request the judge who is responsible for hearing cases related to the Anti-Corruption Department to oversee the hearing of this case.

On the side of the Additional Government Pleader, it was assured that the court’s recommendation would be accepted and a policy regarding book procurement would be formulated and issued within 8 weeks.
On Kamatchi’s side, it was stated that "in this case, some innocent people have been added as accused and suspended from service."
The judges stated, "Those who have been suspended can file separate petitions and obtain the relief they need," and ordered that notices be sent to the then School Education Department Secretary Chandramohan, the then Public Libraries Department Director Jayanthi, and High-Level Committee member Aarthi to provide explanations. They also ordered that all documents related to the purchase of books be submitted to the court and adjourned the case for 4 weeks
