The Madras High Court has ordered that the marriage registration conducted in 2009 between a man belonging to the Christian faith and a woman belonging to the Hindu faith is invalid. In this case, which had been ongoing for 16 years, the court clarified that under the Hindu Marriage Act, only two Hindus can marry.
The marriage registration that took place in 2009... what happened?
Marriage registration between Naveen Kumar and Vigneshwari, both from Chennai, took place on February 20, 2009, at the Chennai Central District Registrar’s Office. However, Naveen Kumar said that he had come to Chennai only to sign as a witness to the marriage, but that he and Vigneshwari had been registered as married.
He said that he belongs to the Christian faith and that the two of them did not live as husband and wife after the marriage. He filed a case in the Chennai Family Court in 2010, seeking a declaration that this marriage registration was invalid.

However, the Family Welfare Court dismissed the case in 2019, saying that the evidence for Naveen Kumar’s conversion to Christianity was not reliable and that there was no evidence to support the claim that he had been forced into the marriage. He appealed this in the Madras High Court.
You cannot determine religion by a name!
Naveen Kumar had submitted baptism certificates in court to prove that he belonged to the Christian faith. However, the Family Court did not accept his religious identity, considering it contradictory that he had been baptized twice in different years.
Hearing the matter, the High Court noted that in the Christian faith, it may be customary for a person to be baptized again when changing to another denomination. It also stated that a person’s religion cannot be determined merely from his name or from government documents such as Aadhaar, voter ID card, or family card.
The court, having accepted the evidence that Naveen Kumar was a Christian, confirmed that he was a member of the Christian faith at the time the marriage was registered.
If it is registered under the Hindu Marriage Act, is it valid?
Under Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, only two persons belonging to the Hindu religion can marry under that Act. Registration of a marriage under Section 8 is merely the procedure for registering an already legally solemnized marriage; a marriage does not become valid by registration alone.
In this case, the court noted that the woman, who was the respondent, also admitted that no marriage ceremony had taken place. Furthermore, the two had not married under the Special Marriage Act either. Therefore, the court ruled that this registration made under the Hindu Marriage Act was not legally valid.

High Court order to marriage registrars!
The court pointed out that, in this case, details relating to religion had been incorrectly recorded at the time of the marriage registration, and that important information, including complete details of the person who solemnized the marriage, had been omitted.
Noting that it had become necessary to cancel an invalid marriage registration after 16 years, the judges ordered that a copy of this judgment be sent to the Inspector General of Registration (IG of Registration). They also directed that it be circulated to marriage registrars across Tamil Nadu to ensure that the proper legal procedures are followed.
This ruling has also confirmed that people belonging to different religions, such as Christians and Hindus, must follow the proper procedures under the Special Marriage Act, 1954, in order to marry without changing their religion.